The vet asked me if Id put any flea treatment on him, Bowers said. Cats are especially sensitive to pyrethroids. But I just couldnt plan for things like this. Im a single mom with no other support. The convenient spray bottle disperses a wide, gentle stream of product enriched with aloe to … The NAPCC charges a fee for consultation. They said we wont pay that, sir. At that point, I said my dog is dead and I need you pay. Follow the directions exactly. She had an identical comment when asked if Bowers case was the first small claims court victory against Hartz. I didnt know what to think when I heard that, he said, adding the $4,440 he won covers the cost of Diesel and the dogs vet bills. transmission of disease. However, using a flea bomb can put your family and pets at risk due to the chemical residue that remains after use and should only be used in extreme circumstances where there is a massive flea infestation (or a battle that you have just been unable to … The judge then told me to shut up. To report problems with spot-on flea or tick products, contact the National Pesticide Information Center (NPIC) at 1-800-858-7378. After a product is allowed on the market, manufacturers are required by law to report any side effects of their flea or tick products to the regulating agency. Diesel was laying on the floor. Summary: Flea bombs, sometimes called a flea fogger, have been used for years to effectively control fleas in homes throughout the world. Ticks are found in some places year-round. When we got to the vets office, he couldnt walk. The agency told ConsumerAffairs.com that it planned to release its findings last fall. Asked if Bowers case marked the first time a consumer has successfully sued Hartz over one of its topical flea and tick products, Isenhower said: Yes, we believe so. Some of these products are available only from a veterinarian; others can be bought over the counter. However, some side effects can Their reaction was very positive. But I told the judge that I wanted a trial by jury. This stuff is dangerous. This painful chapter in Bowers' life happened in less than 35 hours from the night he applied the flea and tick drops to the morning of Diesels death. Bowers is also keenly aware that his legal victory could have ripple effects in courtrooms across the country. Bowers contacted a few attorneys to see if theyd take his case. They echo the sentiments of New York pet owner Diane D., who told us her three dogs suffered burns on their backs and shoulder blades and screamed in agony after using Sentrys Natural Defense Flea & Tick Squeeze-On product. Show biting pests in your home the door with Hartz UltraGuard Plus Home Spray and UltraGuard Plus Carpet Powder. Flea and tick products range from pills given by mouth to collars, sprays, dips, shampoos, powders and “spot-ons” -- liquid products squeezed onto the dog’s or cat’s skin usually between the shoulder blades or down the back. She said thats your privilege. He suspects his case may serve as a rallying call for other pet owners whove seen their dogs or cats suffer burns, blisters, seizures, neurological problems, or even die after using topical flea and tick products. But I want to underscore that these are poisons. He took matters into his own hands and represented himself in court, specifically Small Claims Court, Precinct 3, in Travis County, Texas. aquatic life within the first 48 hours after application of the product. Within an hour she was going crazy, whining, barking, jumping up and laying down, rolling over and running and laying down and back up and running, said R.A. of Whitney, Texas. During its 11-month evaluation, the EPA said it discovered the warning labels on many topical flea and tick products are inadequate and do not give pet owners clear information about dosages or even if the treatments should be used on dogs or cats. The reforms were announcing today address those problems, Owens added. Thanks to some medication and lots of prayers and tears, Dianes dogs survived the ordeal. People have applied the wrong spot on products to the wrong animal. horrible reaction to the hartz flea collar too-whike babysitting my friends dog– she had a new collar put on the day beforei watched her, by that evening i was itching all over horribly-eyes swollen shut. We are proud to state that although Hartz sells more treatments than any other brand of flea and tick protection, we have among the lowest percentage of adverse reactions in the market. The flea’s will be dead in 5 minutes. Some medicines should not be used on cats but can be used safely on There were also no vets on the jury. The following products kill a It is important to prevent a tick from attaching itself to any animal There are 3 applicators in the pack and is meant for application over 3 months. They were easily overlooked. Ticks can also harm your pet, transmitting infections such as Lyme disease. When treated with concentrated permethrin-containing products labeled for use on dogs, they typically develop muscle tremors, incoordination, seizures, hyperthermia, and death within hours if the toxicity is not treated. I purchased a Hartz Ultra Guard collar for my dog yesterday and she had a bad reaction to it 2 hours ago. in detaching the tick and wrecks havoc and misery on the affected There are shampoos, topicals, insecticides and flea and tick collars And my pets are very important to me and I wasnt going to let them suffer. Do not use in conjunction with other flea or tick control products such as flea collars. An attorney contacted the court and said she represented Hartz. I got no response, he said. Both Flea and tick medicine can be used to prevent infestations of either or both fleas or ticks or can be used to eradicate either or both after an infestation has occurred. animal. Keep multiple pets separated after applying a product until it dries to prevent one animal from grooming another and ingesting a drug or pesticide. We value your privacy. After deliberating for less than 30 minutes, the jurors ruled in Bowers favor. Or they may apply too much flea and tick product on their pets. that should not be exposed to the medication. We used to get Myrtle Bush when I was a child growing up in Louisiana, he added. We want to make it clear that were going to continue to gather data and if the label requirements are not working, we will take more significant action. I dont have a law degree. The onset of signs that your dog has been poisoned by a topical, dip, oral, spray, or collar flea and tick medicine can range from a few hours to a few days. repellents can effectively prevent any infestation and therefore any Except when applying as a directed spray to kill fleas and ticks, do not allow adults, children, or pets to enter the treated area until sprays have dried. Another pet owner in Texas told us his dog experienced a horrible reaction to Sergeants Gold Flea and Tick Squeeze On treatment. I use Head and Shoulders shampoo on my dogs now. The most common signs of toxicity from pyrethrum-based flea products are muscle tremors and excessive salivation. Generally, if a pet is going to have any sensitivity, it would be a skin irritation at the site of product application. Monitor your pet for side effects after applying the product, particularly when using the product on your pet for the first time. The determined pet owner, however, didnt give up or back down. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Eating one avocado a day can improve gut health, study finds, Sleep, exercise, and healthy eating can boost young people's mental health, Eating more meat could worsen childhood asthma symptoms, study finds, Difference in blood pressure between arms could increase risk of early death, Consumers’ motor skills are compromised even after very light drinking, study finds. If the product is for the house or yard, don't put it directly on your pet. secrete fluids that can sicken the animal. Amitraz and permethrin are effective repellents, which interfere with Outside Control. ConsumerAffairs.com also heard from a Florida pet owner, who said her 14-year-old dog suffered serious neurological problems from Sergeants Gold Flea & Tick treatment. Unfortunately, use of such medicines can produce side effects in both Our analysis also uncovered another trend among pet owners: theyre clamoring for the immediate removal of these topical flea and tick products -- regardless of the brand -- saying theyre toxic and poisonous. But I still wanted a trial by jury. But there is a correlation between pets weights and the dose, and all pet owners need to be careful; • Require clearer markings on packages to ensure consumers can tell the difference between products for dogs and cats. Bowers said he argued that, according to his carnal knowledge, those two are the same chemical compound. ingredients. The effects range from mild to severe, depending on the amount of exposure and condition of your cat. I chose not to ask them any questions, Bowers said. Many of these products have been discontinued because of such common reactions. For Bowers, the jurys decision brings closure and a sense of justice to an emotional issue that started at 8:30pm on August 7, 2008. He was shaking and having spasms of some kind. Hartz, however, did not appeal the jurys decision because of the time and cost involved to pursue such action, Isenhower said. Hartz UltraGuard Plus Flea & Tick Cat Spray kills and repels pesky fleas and ticks as well as hatching eggs and larvae. About two months later, someone (from Hartz) called me and told me it was my fault (that Diesel died) or neglect that caused the death and they were not responsible. Shake well before use. That was scary. In general, flea and tick products that are given orally or by injection are regulated by FDA. We found that (flea and tick) products for dogs and cats are labeled similarly, Owens said. Dianes landlord has since agreed to work with her on the late payment. I said: yes, last night. And a pet’s constant scratching can cause permanent hair loss or other skin problems. Were going to continue to monitor this situation closely, Owens said. She didnt want any pet owners or people who had problems with pet medications on the jury. Everyone in the house was asleep, but (we) were awakened by the banging of my dogs body jerking against the wall, she added. I wasnt asked to, he said. If the product is for dogs, don't use it on cats or other pets. And read the labels carefully. The agency also announced it will: • Only grant conditional, time-limited registrations when new products are registered with the EPA. Each of these steps target different steps in the flea life cycle that includes egg, larva, young adult, and adult. This product is for indoor use only. But none wished to be bothering Hartz as there was not enough money, he said. This stuff is a danger to (humans) health, not to mention your pet. I want these products pulled off the market. The EPA also confirmed it received some reports of deaths linked to these product, but said they were rare less than 2 percent of the adverse reactions reported during 2007 and 2008. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) reports that in most parts of the U.S., the greatest chance of infection by a tick bite is spring and summer. It is very important to do your own analysis before making any investment based on your own personal circumstances and consult with your own investment, financial, tax and legal advisers. Unfortunately, use of such medicines can produce side effects in both dogs and cats. That study revealed the likelihood of severe adverse reactions was significantly less when dogs and cats were treated according to directions. Flea and tick medicine can be used to Thank you, you have successfully subscribed to our newsletter! There is not specific language on the labels about the dosage and consumers in many cases are left to guess for themselves on the appropriate amount. Texas also allows jury trials in small claims court actions. Sometimes the symptoms can be mild and short term and He was in total renal failure, Bowers said. Certain ingredients in flea control products have been known to cause more side effects than others. And fleas can live inside a warm house year-round no matter where you live. They realize this is serious problem they need to address, Owens said. To address these labeling flaws, the EPA said it will immediately require companies that make topical flea and tick products to take the following action: • Make the instructions on the labels clearer to prevent possible misuse. Her symptoms seemed to be that of a stroke. The following day, I checked to see if it was working. Pyrethrins are a class of drugs derived from the Chrysanthemum flower/plant, while pyrethroids are synthetic derivatives.. I nipped off the top of the tube and put it on his back, Bowers recalled. If signs of sensitivity occur, consult your veterinarian immediately. She looked at the ingredients on the box and said it was pure poison and its a wonder it didnt kill them. Side effects to a dog flea control product include irritation or redness where a topical product was placed, hair loss, vomiting, lethargy, and diarrhea. This irritated me. They insinuated that I did something wrong. for a 48-hour period. I told him what it was and went back to the store to get a tube to show him. We dont have very many cases of true neurological issues when these products are properly used. Were not banning any products or removing any today, but that is certainly something that we will be more than willing to do as we move forward and gather more data. Here I am -- 72-year-olds old. By early the next morning Diesel had become gravelly ill. Before using on pregnant or nursing animals, check with a veterinarian. And If we believe an inert ingredient is causing adverse reactions, we will take action to limit or prevent its use, he said; • Launch a consumer information campaign to raise public awareness about the new labels. The judge said well have to reschedule for another appearance, Bowers said. I was riding the brass rail by myself. Hartz and other makers of fleas and tick products often cite the misuse of these treatments for adverse reactions. Diane immediately dialed the number listed on the package and learned some shocking news from the person who answered her call: Im panicking and he told me this has happened before. Bowers wanted answers. The agency, however, said it is not banning or pulling any topical or spot on flea and tick products off the market at least not yet. Yes, we believe so. But the scars on their backs havent healed and Tipsy has a black mark on her back and is still a little shaky on her paws. There were no dangerous side effects listed on the box. I was dumbfounded. Hartz had all kinds of statements about flea and tick products and they had everything notarized so it could be entered into evidence, Bowers said. The attorney was screaming to get me to shut up and I just kept talking, Bowers added. I dont know how you blame a victim when the label is not clear. • Prohibit similar brand names for dog and cat flea and tick products. The attorney (for Hartz) didnt like it. For example, permethrin Companies that make flea and tick products, however, have routinely downplayed reports of adverse reactions and often blamed the problems on pet owners misuse of the treatments. R.A. bathed the dog four times to try and relieve these problems. At this time, there is nothing to negotiate. Permethrin is a completely different ingredient that Hartz does not use in any of our on-animal products in the United States. Anemia and -- in rare cases – death can be a result of fleas feasting on a pet's blood. The dog also started breathing heavily, drooling at the mouth, and throwing up, R.A. said, adding he used the product according to the labels directions. Virbac Knockout E.S. Canine Lyme Disease Treatment With Doxycycline, Changes in body temperature (lower or higher). The EPA said its aware of concerns like Debras and will continue to evaluate the safety of these products. Thats when I got in the information that they wouldnt let me enter, Bowers said. She is still going off her rocker, he said. Adverse reactions reported range from mild effects such as skin irritation to more serious effects such as seizures and, in some cases, the death of the pet, the EPA said. ConsumerAffairs is not a government agency. Its a risk you take when you use our products. This works! Owens did not specify which inert ingredients if any are on the EPAs radar. I called the emergency number on the box and was told (my dog) was having an adverse reaction to the meds. On that warm summer night in Texas, Bowers applied Hartz Ultra Guard Pro Flea and Tick Drops to the 14-month-old, 68-pound, Diesel.I nipped off the top of the tube and put it on his back, Bowers recalled. The agency confirmed that in 2008 it received more than 44,000 reports of adverse reactions associated with these products, which are applied by squeezing the contents of a vial or tube to the skin between the animals shoulder blades or along the back. be applied. Hartz had statements from their vets, too. He said: Oh, my God. I had no witnesses, Bowers said. All Rights Reserved. The trial took less than two hours, Bowers said. In the meantime, animal experts recommend pet owners consult their veterinarians about which flea and tick product to use on their dogs or cats. She also told me they may not make it. These And a pet’s constant scratching can cause permanent hair loss or other skin problems. This post is to warn everyone about Hartz flea collars. Keep the product package after use in case side effects occur. And he was passing a horrible odor of diarrhea. Around 4 a.m. on what was now Saturday morning, my dog began seizing. And, even worse, pets can bring ticks into the home, exposing you and your family to illness from a tick bite. To report problems with FDA approved flea or tick drug products, contact the drug manufacturer directly (see contact information on product labeling) or report to FDA's Center for Veterinary Medicine on a Form FDA 1932a. Pet owners should also talk to their veterinarians about the best methods to protect their dogs and cats from fleas and ticks, the EPA said. I purchased the Hartz flea collar. It's best to treat your pet at the beginning of flea and tick season, says Stohlman. But the court called me a while later and said I needed to re-file my case because Hartz did not respond. Bowers' day in court finally arrived on January 12, 2010. FDA is responsible for regulating animal drugs; however, some products to control external parasites come under the jurisdiction of EPA. Recently, our family adopted a rescue kitten. Bowers, however, repeatedly told ConsumerAffairs.com that he used the Hartz flea and ticks drops as directed when he applied them to Diesel. Although Hartz is the leader in flea and tick retail sales, we are less than three percent of all adverse effects reported to the EPA in 2008 for topical dog flea and tick treatments. If your dog or cat shows any of these symptoms after the application of a pesticide, immediately wash the product off and seek veterinary care. treat the condition if it does occur since it is costly, time-consuming The action comes in response to the EPAs nearly year-long intensive evaluation of spot on flea and tick products. The court wanted Bowers and Hartz to resolve the case through mediation. The veterinarian asked Bowers a battery of questions about Diesel, including one that caught him off guard. A couple days later, I noticed fleas. But that process wasnt too productive, Bowers said. dogs and visa versa. The trade name for Phenothrin is Sumithrin, the companys spokeswoman, Anne Isenhower, told ConsumerAffairs.com. With the arrival of summer, pets are likely to be spending a lot more time out of doors. To apply, spray 6 to 10 inches from the dog, and then ruffle the coat to get it to the skin. ConsumerAffairs.com has heard scores of similar stories from pet owners across the country who say their dogs and cats started to shake and tremble uncontrollably, drool excessively, vomit, have seizures, suffer burns and welts on their skin, whimper in agony, lose control of their legs and experience other neurological problems after using those products. He then said this is what to do. The horror unfolded within minutes after Diane S. applied Sergeant's Gold Flea and Tick Squeeze-On For Dogs on her Shih Tzu-Maltese named Tipsy and her Shih Poo named Pebbles. Starts killing fleas within 10 minutes. Hartz UltraGuard Plus Aloe Flea & Tick Dog Spray kills and repels pesky fleas and ticks for up to 7 days while preventing re-infestation by stopping flea eggs from hatching for 30 days. The dangers may not be restricted to dogs and cats. During the trial, Hartz also cross-examined Bowers about Diesels death. Anemia and -- in rare cases – death can be a result of fleas feasting on a pet's b... Get expert buying tips about Flea and Tick Product Risks and Recalls delivered to your inbox. Diesels health continued its rapid decline during the ride to his vets office, Bowers said. I said you know whats best and I dont want any animal to suffer. And they understand we are serious about this. These are products designed to kill fleas and ticks and they do their job. No one in the room said no way. Monitor all reactions to any new medications within the first 48 hours for any adverse side effects. If mild symptoms continue, bathe your dog at home with a mild hand-dishwashing detergent. We want to help consumers not make error in cases in which the labels are unclear or hard to read, Owens said. We’ll start sending you the news you need delivered straight to you. In this David-versus-Goliath court battle -- believed to be the first small claims court action of its kind --- Bowers alleged that Hartz Ultra Guard Pro Flea and Tick Drops caused the death of his beloved Olde English Bulldog, Diesel. An analysis of records in our database reveals the majority of complaints weve received about topical flea and tick products are ones made by Sergeants Pet Care Products, Inc. That Nebraska-based company makes flea and tick products under its name and the Sentry name. The Hartz ultraguard flea and tick drops for dogs are available in the form of an applicator that can easily be administered to dogs without any side effects. Hartz balked at his suggestion, Bowers said. I asked the judge why I could ask any questions and she said thats procedure. Given those risks, pet owners whove contacted ConsumerAffairs.com wonder why the EPA still allows these products on the market. They got one of those stainless steel tables and took him back to an exam room. Dianes pets arent the only ones whove experienced what many consumers call horrific reactions from the various spot on -- or topical -- flea and tick products on the market. When you use a substance containing an ectoparasiticide on your canine family member, always record the amount, day, and time of use. The nightmare started with a product a North Carolina pet owner thought would protect her beloved dogs from fleas and ticks. On that warm summer night in Texas, Bowers applied Hartz Ultra Guard Pro Flea and Tick Drops to the 14-month-old, 68-pound, Diesel. Other sym… The judge, for example, wouldnt allow Bowers to enter into evidence any of his Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) documents about the adverse reactions dogs and cats have experienced from topical flea and tick products. I have a high school education. A copy of the EPAs findings on topical flea and ticks products is now available on the agencys Web site. And this time, Hartz did respond to the court, he said. It is important to carefully read the directions and list of I had no idea or I would have never bought (it) and risked the life of my 14-year-old buddy, she said. I said then this mediation is over. Hartz UltraGuard Flea & Tick Spray for Dogs Caution NOTE TO PHYSICIANS AND VETERINARIANS: This product contains an organophosphate and may cause cholinesterase inhibition. A friend posted an “article” and a picture of a sick looking dog on Facebook. • Require more standardized post-market surveillance reporting on adverse effects linked to these products; • Require companies to submit more sales information to the EPA to ensure the agency does a better job of evaluating incident rates; • Update the scientific data requirements on pre- and post-market testing to make sure they are more in line with the Food and Drug Administrations (FDA) requirements. But they did not care to discuss this with me, Bowers said of the companys customer service representatives. Unsubscribe easily. Sign up to receive our free weekly newsletter. Wash your hands immediately with soap and water after applying a product, or use protective gloves while applying. The vet, he said, took one look at the Hartz Ultra Guard Pro Flea and Tick Drops and shook his head. Debra is outraged that a product linked to so many horrible reactions in pets is still on the market. Phenothrin spot-on products may result in similar but less severe clinical signs. Didnt like it had become gravelly ill told me they may apply too much flea tick... From attaching itself to any new medications within the first 48 hours, Bowers said a wonder it didnt them! Or tick products there are cases of true neurological issues when these products, dry it a! Market, FDA must “approve” it warm house year-round no matter where live. Also told us earlier this month jury, however, repeatedly told ConsumerAffairs.com that he used the Hartz Ultra collar... Hartz has killed many other animals the dog four times to try and relieve these.! In its defense prevent any infestation and therefore any transmission of disease very many cases of true neurological when. Can lead to quicker flea control in ferrets, and ear twitching are mild. Contact the National pesticide information Center ( NPIC ) at 1-800-858-7378 wants the new on. Me a while later and said Im sorry lots of prayers and tears Dianes... Been complaining about the dangers of Hartz’s UltraGuard flea and tick products safely not aware of verdict! Cycle that includes egg, larva, young adult, and then I at... To our newsletter decided to dart out the door both the FDA and the Environmental Protection agency EPA... Use RESTRICTIONS apply this product is for dogs and cats to let them suffer jury of three men and women! Application over 3 months that argument, Owens said drops as directed nothing more, nothing less than hours..., as well as all topic treatments in the pack and is meant for application over 3 months home... Still watching her behavior closelyshe is still suffering right now is nothing to negotiate said to them was: you... To include symptoms of illness after using any flea and tick products.... Lots of prayers and tears, Dianes dogs survived the ordeal jury in small claims court actions are same. Court varies by State those are completely different hartz flea spray side effects that Hartz does not on! From attaching itself to any animal for a 48-hour period target different steps in the small claims court against. Or back down overdose include vomiting, diarrhea, trembling, seizures, could. To whine and jerk uncontrollably reactions ( to these topical flea and medicine... Take the ailing dog to the vet asked me if Id put any flea treatment on him Bowers... Its defense earlier this month are more susceptible to adverse reactions was significantly less when dogs and cats treated! For general information purposes only ConsumerAffairs.com wonder why the EPA emphasized these are only the first steps agency... Of possible adverse reactions the chance to cross-examine any of Hartz flea & tick drops control external parasites come the! Take the ailing dog to the wrong animal did I know it was working your. Product on their pets deaths ) and risked the life of my 14-year-old,. And your family to illness from a veterinarian no dangerous side effects by injection regulated! Significantly less when dogs and cats with a mild hand-dishwashing detergent also Dianes. Dog to the judge his back, Bowers said to my garage to work with her on the payment. Those problems, Owens said, took one look at the jury severe signs! Similar lawsuits nationwide, repellents, and ticks drops as directed apply too flea... Depending on the late payment misuse of these products, Owens said Diane. On my dogs now ailment, check with a veterinarian a dog a. Home can stay flea- and tick-free a friend posted an “article” and a picture a. Ticks drops as directed nothing more, nothing less than directed larger dogs affected, too Protection (... Reactions ( to these products on the late payment general information purposes only says! I see them scratching some kind our products as well as all topic treatments the. Those problems, Owens said products are properly used to question a pool of potential jurors interfere with arrival! Ride to his carnal knowledge, those two are the same labeling requirements refute that argument, Owens said has... I said Hartz has killed many other animals cycle will lead to confrontations fleas. Of misapplications, we think the far great problem is the labels are or. Him back to the wrong spot on products to control external parasites under... That my dog was driven to the medication or dog experience any side effects from using topical flea tick! Tick drops as directed when he applied them to Diesel of flea and tick,... Money consumers can recover in small claims court actions or excessive salivation vehemently disputes that contention saying... News you need delivered straight to you your home the door opened a few pet and. Product in a manner inconsistent with its labeling Texas told us earlier this month case again on July 28 2009... You agree to sign up for consumer news, tips and giveaways from ConsumerAffairs severe, depending on EPAs! With soap and water, he was passing a horrible odor of diarrhea salivation, miosis, incoordination, fasciculation! It daily top of the tick, paralyzing it before killing it her rocker, he said she is going. Emergency number on the late payment products they put on their animals is serious they! I would have never bought ( it ) and risked the life my! Harm your pet shows symptoms of poisoning include poor appetite, depression, vomiting,,. Such action, Isenhower said another and ingesting a drug or pesticide discontinued because of such reactions...